(ASIL) American Society of International Law

Readers' Corner


This section of the Newsletter succinctly reviews books of interest to members. I would like to especially thank Martinus Nijhoff for its continuing support of this workproduct of the ASIL. The entries are arranged alphabetically by subject area for ease of reader reference. Address information for the referenced publishers ( ) is listed at the end of this section of the Newsletter.

Topical Headings

Africa Religion
Arms Control Int'l Organization Treatises
Careers/Scholarships Int'l Relations United Nations
Diplomacy Latin America Use of Force
Economics Private Int'l Law Publishers Information
Environment NAFTA Human Rights

Africa



Arms Control


F. Tanner (ed.), FROM VERSAILLES TO BAGHDAD: POST-WAR ARMAMENT CONTROL OF DEFEATED STATES (UN, 1992) [264] -

The UN Institute for Disarmament Research (UNDIR) was created in 1980. This contribution explores approaches to the resolution of this recurring problem. Its objective is to provide relevant details about the interrelated pursuit of increased security via decreased armaments. This particular project is the fruit of two years of research by UNDIR and the Graduate Institute of International Studies in Geneva, with financial assistance from the Swiss Government. The study illustrates that post-war arms control regimes are marked by the objective circumstances resulting from the particular conflict. There does not appear to be any standardized "peace treaty," for example, that one could use to typify how the victor deals with the vanquished. There are some common features, however, which raise the question of the long-range utility of coerced treaties that are not the product of a negotiated post-war settlement.

Nine authors, from different countries, structured this project in eight chapters on the following subjects: (1) German disarmament after Versailles; (2) the Italian Peace Treaty of 1947; (3) the military clauses of the (Paris) Allied Peace Treaties with Rumania, Bulgaria, and Hungary; (4) Finland and the Peace Treaty of 1947; (5) the 1954 Brussels Treaty Protocol regarding German arms control; (6) Japan; (7) the 1955 Austrian Treaty's arms limitation provisions; and (8) the UN/Iraq mass weapons elimination regime. This portion of the text provides a wealth of useful detail not readily available from any other source (between two covers).

The appendixes are the other half of this study. They provide the original provisions from which the authors draw both data and their conclusions in this one-of-a-kind research project.

Careers/Scholarships



Diplomacy


G. Berridge, TALKING TO THE ENEMY: HOW STATES WITHOUT `DIPLOMATIC RELATIONS' COMMUNICATE (St. Martins Press, 1994) [178] -

This is a fascinating account of the behind-the-scenes negotiations when States, or other international actors who are not officially talking to each other must nevertheless communicate. Contemporary examples include the Israeli/PLO and Great Britain/Sinn Fein negotiations--sometimes so secret that the very fact of the discussions could trigger violence. There are also the classic examples of the Swiss and Czech embassies during the early days of the US/Cuban crisis of the 1960s, the Iran/US hostage negotiations of the late 1970s, and the Sino-American rapproachment of the 1980s.

The author structures the chapters in terms of the various devices for actually conducting such negotiations: Shuttered Embassy; Intermediary; Disguised Embassy; Working Funeral; Diplomatic Corps; Special Envoy; and the Joint Commission. These chapters evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of each device. One of the most interesting features of this study is the frequency with which mortal enemies have engaged in these unofficial meetings in each decade since the end of World War II.

This book provides useful depth, for teachers emphasizing diplomacy in their international courses; and, interesting reading for anyone searching for information on the full panoply of diplomatic relations.

Economics


J. Nesbitt, GLOBAL PARADOX: THE BIGGER THE WORLD ECONOMY, THE MORE POWERFUL ITS SMALLEST PLAYERS (William Morrow & Co., 1994) [304] -

As the contemporary breakdown of sovereignty continues, there is an emerging paradox that forms the core of this "best seller." As States and multinational corporations break down into smaller entities, less rigid economic entities are on the rise. This phenomenon is rooted in the degree of modern global communications. Telecommunications thus link Ethiopia with Detroit, rural and urban communities, and public and private entities throughout the world.

Tourism, for example, is probably the fastest growing international business. Third World countries can use it to upgrade their economies, moreso than relying on the strings attached to foreign aid. It incites the interest of many States in distant cultures and tribes. The author's premise is that the more universal "we" become, the more tribal we act. The demise of sovereignty, in the sense elicited by terms like "Westphalia" and "Soviet Union," is empowering new and smaller groups that are undertaking the marketplace operations of the traditional State or multinational corporation.

Each issue, I try to include a publication that is somewhat broader than our usual reading list. There is no doubt that you will find this one both a fascinating and instructive perception of the restructuring international marketplace.

Environment


Human Rights


T. Zwart, THE ADMISSIBILITY OF HUMAN RIGHTS PETITIONS: THE CASE LAW OF THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION ON HUMAN RIGHTS AND THE HUMAN RIGHTS COMMITTEE (Martinus Nijhoff, 1994) [246] -

There are regional and global human rights institutions for receiving individual complaints claiming State responsibility for failing to secure rights guaranteed by the relevant treaties. Unfortunately, these institutions have become rather occupied with their increasing caseload. This study thus addresses the underlying problems with the resulting limitation on human rights enforcement.

Admissibility focuses on one regional, and one global, institution: the European Commission of Human Rights (per Article 19 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms) and the UN Human Rights Committee (per Article 28 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights). The author examines the conditions for admissibility via an analysis of their respective decisions and case law. Ninety % of the European petitions are deemed inadmissible, thus illustrating that the vast majority of the caseload is done at the admissibility stage, rather than dealing with the merits of the individuals' claims.

With certain procedural alterations, the "caseload" of these organs might be ameliorated in the sense that more results could be obtained with less effort. Examples include a more restrictive application of treaty provisions, which would thus eliminate some of the peripheral petitions (e.g., social rights, as opposed to equal protection under law). Another suggested streamlining would be to shift some of the workload to subsidiary organs and/or individuals.

This is a lively and authoritative exploration of ways in which to further support the work of the various human rights international organs by rethinking modes for streamlining their processes. It provides a great deal of useful information for use in the literature of human rights courses.

Int'l Finance


H. Scott & P. Wellons, INTERNATIONAL FINANCE: TRANSACTIONS, POLICY, AND REGULATION (Foundation Press, 1995) [1004] -

This is a new casebook in Foundation's University Casebook Series. It covers the international components of both domestic and offshore markets. It focuses on the relevant governmental policies of the US, European Union, and Japan.

A thirty-page introductory chapter yields the initial insight into a fascinating study of international finance. Other chapters focus on cross-border banking and security activities including investment, capital adequacy, clearance/settlement issues, and monetary exchange regimes.

This appears to be the perfect primer because it provides only the most basic financial theory. Law students would not have to possess a conspicuous sense of banking and securities law as a practical prerequisite for this course. A 246-page manual, containing "Teaching Plans," provides serviceable insight for the first-time teacher.

Int'l Organization


Int'l Relations


A. Osiander, THE STATES SYSTEM OF EUROPE, 1640-1990: PEACEMAKING AND THECONDITIONS OF INTERNATIONAL STABILITY (Oxford Univ. Press, 1994) [358] -

While other books contain information regarding the evolution of the State system since the Peace of Westphalia, this one is particularly useful for those seeking a precise analysis of the history of the State under "modern" International Law.

The author examines the four European peace processes: Munster and Osnabruck (1644-1648); Utrecht (1712-1715); Vienna (1814-1815); and Paris (1919-1920). These international congresses shaped the evolution--for better or for worse--of the contemporary terms "balance of power" and "self-determination."

The underlying premise of this book is that the structure of the State system does not depend on common facts of international life such as conflict. Rather, it depends on "consensus principles" which influence States in the conduct of their international relations. The "European" system did not evolve instantly. There was (and is) a certain ebb and flow of behavioral norms that erode and return over long periods of time. This work presents the underlying structure of the principles affecting long-term State relations.

Latin America


P. Calvert, THE INTERNATIONAL POLITICS OF LATIN AMERICA (Manchester Univ. Press, 1994) [261] -

This would be a useful textbook for undergraduate professors who incorporate Latin American perspectives into various international courses. It describes State interaction and their involvement in regional peacekeeping and International Law.

Laws of War


NAFTA


C. DeFouloy, GLOSSARY OF NAFTA TERMS (Martinus Nijhoff, 1994) [135] - The bulk of this paperback is a detailed listing of defined NAFTA-related terms, arranged in convenient alphabetical order. Its brief definitions succinctly identify the significant terms and their essential meaning, thus providing a useful reference handbook between two covers, for terms appearing in the 2,000-page NAFTA. It also includes terms used in other hemispheric contexts--for example, the various trade arrangements involving the Caribbean, Central America, and South America.

Appendix I lists common acronyms and abbreviations. Appendix II provides a convenient listing of the western hemisphere's international trade organizations--in three languages (English, French, and Spanish). Appendix III is a useful listing of addresses where additional information is available regarding NAFTA and other hemispheric economic arrangements (including media and university locations).

Private Int'l Law


  • P. North & J. Fawcett, CHESIRE AND NORTH'S PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW (Butterworths, 1992) [936] -

    This edition continues a noble tradition in Private International Law (PIL or Conflicts of Law) begun in 1935. While considered the standard reference text for conflicts studies in many English-speaking nations, this work also serves as a guidepost for practitioners--particularly those beyond "the Continent" who seek handy evidence of English and Community practice.

    The major revisions in this edition include the Contracts and Trusts chapters to accommodate, respectively, the British Contracts Act of 1990 and the Recognition of Trusts Act of 1987; case law from the European Court of Justice and British courts; and developments in response to the Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments Act of 1991. The authors also discuss proposed Law Commission revisions and their potential impact on PIL.

    There are no major "structural" changes to what is already the standard work in the field. There is some considerable rewriting to update coverage.

  • P. Nygh, CONFLICT OF LAWS IN AUSTRALIA (5th ed. Butterworths, 1991) [548] -

    This will be a jewel for any Conflicts collection that emphasizes diversity in perspectives. It is written by a judge of the Family Court of Australia, with degrees from Sydney and the University of Michigan. This edition embraces the many changes occurring in Australian conflicts law during the latter 1980s. There have been fascinating development in terms of a distinct law of inter-Australian conflicts, and new legislation on admiralty, checks (written instruments), corporations, and family law.

    The treatment of the subject is divided into nine parts. Part I General introduces the subject, emphasizing conflicts within Australia and doctrinal theories; Part II Procedural analyzes jurisdiction, inappropriate forum, and State immunity; Part III enforcement/awards addresses both inter-Australian and foreign judgments; Part IV covers the choice of law paradigm, with all of the usual academic and judicial trimmings; Part V covers obligations and torts; Part VI provides a comprehensive analysis of family law; Part VII covers property; Part VIII bankruptcy and corporations; and Part IX devolution on death.

    This edition continues to expose the divergences between the British roots and the relatively recent evolution of distinctly Australian perspectives in the last decade--as evidenced by the various courts and the Legislature. A number of these differences have resulted from Australia's adoption of various UN model conventions on conflict of laws.

    Religion


    D. Johnston & C. Sampson (ed.), RELIGION, THE MISSING DIMENSION OF STATECRAFT (Oxford Univ. Press, 1994) [350] -

    Course texts in International Law are beginning to more fully identify the influence of religion on the evolution of International Law. There has been a historical association between religion and war, spawned by the Natural Law notion of the Just War (the best example being Mark Janis's Influence of Religion on International Law, reviewed in a prior issue of the Newsletter).

    This reader, introduced by former President Jimmy Carter's Foreword, is a collection of fifteen analyses by different authors. The underlying theme is to explore the role of religion in the conduct of international relations during the era known as Modern International Law. The separation of Church and State in countries like the US is not the only model. Also, the demise of the Soviet Union has affected emerging eastern European approaches, previously suppressed during prior decades.

    This publication provides fresh perspectives that identify the influence of religion on the apartheid, rearmament, sanctuary, the conduct war, etc. It is a useful attempt to sensitize the reader to the integrated relation between these two disciplines--previously considered by some as unnecessary to a full understanding of the evolution of International Law.

    Treatises


    I. Shearer, STARKE'S INTERNATIONAL LAW (11th ed. Butterworths, 1994) [629] -

    This perspective, by the University of Sydney's Professor of International Law, continues the intellectually stimulating tradition begun in 1947. This treatment maintains the structure and flavor of the earlier work, although it provides new perspectives drawn from events including the end of the Cold War and the "renaissance" of the Security Council in the immediate aftermath of the Persian Gulf War. It is, essentially, an update, of an already lucid treatment of the field of International Law.

    Its twenty chapters begin, of course, with the nature, sources, and subjects of International Law. Ensuing chapters move through further details associated with the State as the primary actor in International Law--sovereignty, jurisdiction, Law of the Sea, State responsibility, and succession. The middle chapters address economic interests of the State, the environment, and international transactions. The closing chapters cover treaties, war, and finally, international institutions.

    This treatise will be a useful addition to any collection seeking diversity of coverage so as to include Australian perspectives.

    Use of Force


    R. Beck, THE GRENADA INVASION: POLITICS, LAW, AND FOREIGN POLICY DECISIONMAKING (Westview Press, 1993) [262] -

    This publication is an impressive assessment of the role of International Law in the US foreign policy decisions related to the Grenada invasion of 1983--specifically, how the Reagan Administration invoked International Law to support its actions. It nicely plugs one portion of the ever-present analytical gap between law and politics in International Law.

    This book is not a matter that should be relegated to only history. There is no more Cold War, Soviet Union, and worldwide specter of nuclear proliferation. But the unilateral use of force in such contexts continues to be the most forceful test of the efficacy of International Law. While it focuses on UN Charter principles regarding the use of force, the author points out that it is impossible to articulate the precise impact of the role of International Law on policy analysis and decisionmaking.

    The chapters address the various stages in the days before, during, and after the invasion of Grenada; and, the methodology employed to incorporate international legal principles into the US decisionmaking.

    [Home]


    Copyright 1997 American Society of International Law